Bush and Katrina (continued)

The battle over Bush's failure to respond effectively to the Katrina disaster continues. Maureen Dowd in the NYT is spot on. Meanwhile Christopher Hitchens in the Ottawa Citizen mounts a feeble attempt to defend Bush and blames the Mayor and the State instead. From what I read elsewhere (see below) the Mayor has waged a valiant battle against impossible odds.

September 7, 2005
Haunted by Hesitation

It took a while, but the president finally figured out a response to the destruction of New Orleans.

Later this week (no point rushing things) W. is dispatching Dick Cheney to the rancid lake that was a romantic city. The vice president has at long last lumbered back from a Wyoming vacation, and, reportedly, from shopping for a $2.9 million waterfront estate in St. Michael's, a retreat in the Chesapeake Bay where Rummy has a weekend home, where "Wedding Crashers" was filmed and where rich lobbyists hunt.

Maybe Mr. Cheney is going down to New Orleans to hunt looters. Or to make sure that Halliburton's lucrative contract to rebuild the city is watertight. Or maybe, since former Senator John Breaux of Louisiana described the shattered parish as "Baghdad under water," the vice president plans to take his pal Ahmad Chalabi along for a consultation on destroying minority rights.

The water that breached the New Orleans levees and left a million people homeless and jobless has also breached the White House defenses. Reality has come flooding in. Since 9/11, the Bush administration has been remarkably successful at blowing off "the reality-based community," as it derisively calls the press.

But now, when W., Mr. Cheney, Laura, Rummy, Gen. Richard Myers, Michael Chertoff and the rest of the gang tell us everything's under control, our cities are safe, stay the course - who believes them?

This time we can actually see the bodies.

As the water recedes, more and more decaying bodies will testify to the callous and stumblebum administration response to Katrina's rout of 90,000 square miles of the South.

The Bush administration bungled the Iraq occupation, arrogantly throwing away State Department occupation plans and C.I.A. insurgency warnings. But the human toll of those mistakes has not been as viscerally evident because the White House pulled a curtain over the bodies: the president has avoided the funerals of soldiers, and the Pentagon has censored the coffins of the dead coming home and never acknowledges the number of Iraqi civilians killed.

But this time, the bodies of those who might have been saved between Monday and Friday, when the president failed to rush the necessary resources to a disaster that his own general describes as "biblical," or even send in the 82nd Airborne, are floating up in front of our eyes.

New Orleans's literary lore and tourist lure was its fascination with the dead and undead, its lavish annual Halloween party, its famous above-ground cemeteries, its love of vampires and voodoo and zombies. But now that the city is decimated, reeking with unnecessary death and destruction, the restless spirits of New Orleans will haunt the White House.

The administration's foreign policy is entirely constructed around American self-love - the idea that the U.S. is superior, that we are the model everyone looks up to, that everyone in the world wants what we have.

But when people around the world look at Iraq, they don't see freedom. They see chaos and sectarian hatred. And when they look at New Orleans, they see glaring incompetence and racial injustice, where the rich white people were saved and the poor black people were left to die hideous deaths. They see some conservatives blaming the poor for not saving themselves. So much for W.'s "culture of life."

The president won re-election because he said that the war in Iraq and the Homeland Security Department would make us safer. Hogwash.

W.'s 2004 convention was staged like "The Magnificent Seven" with the Republicans' swaggering tough guys - from Rudy Giuliani to Arnold Schwarzenegger to John McCain - riding in to save an embattled town.

These were the steely-eyed gunslingers we needed to protect us, they said, not those sissified girlie-men Democrats. But now it turns out that W. can't save the town, not even from hurricane damage that everyone has been predicting for years, much less from unpredictable terrorists.

His campaigns presented the arc of his life story as that of a man who stumbled around until he was 40, then found himself and developed a laserlike focus.

But now that the people of New Orleans need an ark, we have to question the president's arc. He's stumbling in Iraq and he's stumbling on Katrina.

Let's play the blame game: the man who benefited more than anyone in history from safety nets set up by family did not bother to provide one for those who lost their families.

E-mail: liberties@nytimes.com

Mayor hailed for courage during hurricane
Crisis chief promises to clean up his city

Richard Foot
The Ottawa Citizen

September 7, 2005

CREDIT: Nicholas Kamm, AFP, Getty Images
New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin's actions during Hurricane Katrina have been called 'courageous.'

NEW ORLEANS - Mayor Ray Nagin strode to a microphone on the steps of New Orleans City Hall yesterday -- days of relentless pressure etched on his face -- and told reporters that nine days after Hurricane Katrina struck, his beloved city remained beset by fire, floods and toxic gases.

"It's a very volatile situation here right now," he said. "I want everybody to get out, because it's a real health risk being here. There are toxins in the water, there are mosquitoes biting dead bodies ... let's clean this city up, and once we clean it, I promise everyone will be able to come back."

In a disaster defined as much by its inept handling and political bickering as by the strength of its winds and floods, Mr. Nagin is emerging as one of the few high-profile heroes at the centre of the storm.

It was Mr. Nagin -- although warned by advisers as Katrina approached that City Hall didn't have the power to enforce an evacuation order -- who ordered one anyway.

And it was Mr. Nagin who, after the storm, never shied from pointing fingers at President George W. Bush and other federal and state authorities for government aid and equipment that took days to materialize.

When catastrophe overcame his city, Mr. Nagin had few real resources at his disposal -- beyond the police and fire departments -- to deal with the tragedy.

"We fought this battle from Monday to Thursday, with the mayor leading us through it, with little or no help from outside," says New Orleans police Capt. Marlon Defillo. "There was nothing for us to eat, nowhere for us to sleep, no clothes to change into, and it was our courageous mayor who told the outside world that we couldn't get the resources we needed from the country in the proper fashion."

Mr. Nagin has surprised observers since his unexpected victory in the city's mayoral election in 2002.

He won office that year -- the first person in 60 years to occupy the mayor's chair without prior political experience -- promising to rid the city of its systemic municipal graft and corruption.

Since then, he has created a criminal and administrative probe that led to the arrest of 84 city workers and the wholesale restructuring of the public utilities department.

Such hard-headed determination has served him well in the current crisis.

The city itself did not own a single helicopter before the storm. After Katrina struck, Mr. Nagin got on the phone to pester neighbouring municipalities into lending him theirs.

Long before the military arrived, he and his police force had two borrowed municipal choppers at their disposal.

But what most impresses his colleagues at City Hall, particularly the beleaguered officers on the police force, is that Mr. Nagin hasn't once left his post throughout the disaster, surviving for several days like the rest of his police officers inside the dark and abandoned floors of the Hyatt hotel, without power, running water, and fresh food.

Although his wife and three children were safely moved from the city, Mr. Nagin stayed to witness, endure -- and try to solve -- its dramatic breakdown.

Hurricane Katrina

© The Ottawa Citizen 2005

No comments: